Turtle Soup Trading: Failed Breakout Strategy Explained

Turtle Soup Trading: Failed Breakout Strategy Explained

TopFxBrokers
October 28, 2026
Source: Multiple sources

Turtle soup trading is a reversal approach that bets against a breakout once it fails. Price pokes past a key high or low, catches breakout traders on the wrong side, then returns inside the earlier range. This guide shows how the setup forms, how the original and ICT versions differ, and where the main risks sit.

Quick Answer

Turtle soup trading means entering against a breakout after it has failed. The trader waits for price to close back inside the old range and places the stop just beyond the failed extreme. No source offers a reliable universal win rate, so each trader needs to test the exact rules they plan to use.

How Turtle Soup Trading Works

Many traders buy when price clears a recent high. Many sell when price drops under a recent low. Sometimes the move stalls and reverses, and those breakout traders are trapped.

A turtle soup trader aims to take advantage of that failure. A failed push above a high creates a short setup. A failed push below a low creates a long setup.

It is a short-term approach. The stop usually sits just past the false-breakout extreme. If the breakout turns out to be real, the loss is contained.

The Original Connors and Raschke Rules

Laurence Connors and Linda Bradford Raschke introduced Turtle Soup in their book Street Smarts. Most sources give 1995, while some cite 1996 as the book's publication date, so the exact year is unclear. They built it as a direct counter to the Turtle Traders' 20-day breakout system.

The original rules are built on the 20-day high and low. Their main elements are:

  • A new 20-day high or low starts the setup.
  • The previous 20-day extreme must be at least four trading sessions old. This age filter was meant to screen out trending markets.
  • A stop order sits a few ticks beyond the old level. The order fills only after the breakout is already failing.

The book's glossary also lists a variant called Turtle Soup Plus One. It waits one extra day after the new 20-day extreme closes beyond the prior level.

The ICT Liquidity-Sweep Version

The ICT version keeps the failed-breakout logic but changes the vocabulary. Stop orders resting beyond swing highs or lows are called liquidity. A move that reaches them is a liquidity sweep. This version is often used on intraday charts.

Guides on the ICT method commonly describe these features:

  • A wick pokes beyond the level, and the same candle closes back inside the prior range.
  • A close beyond the swept level counts as a genuine breakout, not a Turtle Soup.
  • Some guides look for equal highs or equal lows, a fast sweep and a sharp reversal. A market structure shift on a lower timeframe often serves as confirmation.
  • The stop goes just past the sweep wick, sometimes with a small buffer. Targets are often major liquidity levels such as earlier highs or lows.
  • Some guides place the pattern in the manipulation phase of the AMD (Accumulation, Manipulation, Distribution) framework.

One forex guide calls a typical fakeout a move of 5 to 20 pips past a level such as the previous daily high or low. It reads a larger move without sharp rejection as a real breakout. Only one source gives this range, and it is not standardised across markets. Most ICT material comes from secondary education sites, so exact rules differ from guide to guide.

The two versions differ in several ways:

  • Level used: the original uses 20-day highs and lows. ICT versions use swing levels, equal highs or lows, or higher-timeframe levels.
  • Failure window: the original spans several sessions. One broker guide requires failure within the same day, which conflicts with the original rules.
  • Entry: the original uses a stop order beyond the old level. Beginner and ICT guides usually wait for a close back inside the range.

Step-by-Step: How Traders Apply It

  • Pick one version. Choose the original 20-day rules or an ICT sweep version. Write down every condition, because sources disagree on details.
  • Mark the level. Find the high or low that breakout traders are watching.
  • Skip the breakout itself. Wait for a close back inside the original range. That close confirms the failure.
  • Anchor the stop to the extreme. Place it just beyond the failed high, low or sweep wick, not at an arbitrary distance.
  • Check the bigger picture. Avoid fading breakouts in a strong trend. Treat a close beyond the swept level as a possible genuine breakout.
  • Size by the stop. Base position size on the distance to the stop, so a losing streak stays within your risk limit.
  • Test first. Backtest and forward test your exact rules before risking capital. Judge them by expectancy and risk-to-reward.

Risks, Limits and Choosing a Broker

Strong trends are the main danger. Breakouts often hold in those conditions, so fading them systematically produces repeated stop-outs. Raschke added the age filter to avoid trending markets, but no filter removes this risk.

Win rates are a second problem. One widely cited guide says the setup has no single universal success rate and urges caution with any figure quoted without conditions. The same guide argues that risk-to-reward and consistency matter more than win rate. It says a modest win rate with roughly 3:1 reward-to-risk can work well. That is one guide's view, not a guarantee.

Marketing language deserves care. Some broker and education pages call the setup "high-probability". None of the sources provides independent data to support that label, and most come from firms with commercial interests. Also, one name covers both a 20-day system and intraday sweeps, so results from one version say little about the other.

Turtle Soup is a technical analysis concept, not a regulated product, so no regulator oversees the pattern. Forex trading is overseen by the broker's local regulator. Rules and broker conditions change, so check the broker's licence on that regulator's public register and confirm current terms with the broker. You can compare brokers in the site's reviews, such as the Fxopen review.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Who created turtle soup? Laurence Connors and Linda Bradford Raschke, in Street Smarts. The ICT version later adapted the name and concept.
  • How does it differ from a normal breakout trade? A breakout trader enters with the move once price clears a level. A turtle soup trader waits for the move to fail and enters against it.
  • Is a close beyond the level still turtle soup? In the ICT version, no. Such a close is treated as a genuine breakout.
  • Does turtle soup have a known win rate? No universal figure exists. Your own backtest of fixed rules is the more meaningful measure.
  • Can the same rules be used on any timeframe? Sources do not agree. The original rules use 20-day extremes, while ICT guides often apply the idea intraday, so test the timeframe you plan to trade.

Bottom Line

Turtle soup trading fades breakouts that fail, with a stop just beyond the failed extreme. The original and ICT versions follow different rules, so define one version and test it. Past patterns do not guarantee future results, and strong trends can cause repeated losses.

Related Reading

Sources

This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.